Close to 40 cents of every dollar in an S&P 500 fund now sits in just ten companies, and most of them are betting on the same thing: artificial intelligence. A Reddit post last week said 41 cents; the latest published figure, from State Street on October 20, is about 38.5 cents. Either way, it is the most top-heavy the index has been in modern memory. To see what skipping those names would have meant, I modelled $100,000 put into SCHD (the Schwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF) on October 3, 2016, a fund that owns none of the biggest AI names, and compared it with VOO, the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, every year since.
This is a hypothetical model built on published prices and dividends, not a real account. It is education, not financial advice, and nothing here is a forecast of the AI boom or the market.
Key Takeaways
- The S&P 500 won on wealth: $100,000 became about $416,000 in VOO versus about $352,000 in SCHD, a gap of about $64,000.
- SCHD pays about $10,500 a year today versus about $4,400 for VOO, almost two and a half times the paycheck.
- In 2022 SCHD lost about 3% while the S&P 500 lost about 18%, and SCHD's payout never went down in the test.
- In 2026 SCHD is up about 32% with dividends reinvested versus about 13% for the S&P 500, shrinking the gap from about $102,000 to about $64,000.
- A 50/50 SCHD + VOO split grew to about $384,000 and pays about $620 a month, with roughly 19 cents of every dollar in the top ten.
How Top-Heavy Is the S&P 500 Today?
The top ten holdings, based on fund holdings published around October 20, are Nvidia (a little over 8%), Apple (a little over 7%), Microsoft (almost 6%), Amazon (close to 4%), Alphabet (about 5.5% across its two share classes), Broadcom (about 2.5%), Meta (about 2.5%), Micron (close to 2%) and Tesla (about 1.5%). What do they share? AI chips, clouds that rent AI, phones and software that sell AI features, and even Tesla, now valued partly on robots and self-driving.
Together they make up about 38.5% of the index, per State Street. One analysis reported that the top fifteen stocks hold a record 46.7% of the S&P 500, but that comes from The Kobeissi Letter, so treat it as one source. You still own 500 companies, but your dollar is not spread evenly: roughly eight cents goes to Nvidia, seven to Apple, six to Microsoft, and the remaining sixty cents is split across about 490 other companies.
What Happened the Last Time It Looked Like This (2000)
RBC Wealth Management puts the top ten at roughly 23% of the index in 2000, peaking at about 27%. GWK Investment Management says the top ten peaked at about 25% in 1999. By every measure found, the top of the index is heavier today than at the dot-com peak.
Computed from the index's own daily closes, the S&P 500 hit its high on March 24, 2000, fell about 49% by October 9, 2002, and did not close above that high until May 30, 2007. After the financial crisis, it did not get back above that level until February 2013. The Nasdaq fell about 78% from its March 10, 2000 peak and did not regain it until April 23, 2015.
Today's leaders are not the leaders of 2000: many earn enormous profits, while many then had small profits or none. So this is not a prediction that history repeats, but a reminder of what concentration can cost when the story changes. Timing matters most near retirement: a retiree selling shares during a long slump sells them cheap, which is one reason dividend investors care about income that does not depend on selling.
The AI Spending and Borrowing Behind the Boom
CNBC reported that Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and Meta together called for roughly $730 billion of capital spending this year, with FactSet analysts expecting about $1 trillion next year. The Economist reported that those four borrowed about $214 billion in 2026, against about $83 billion in all of 2025, and put AI-related borrowing across the industry at close to $850 billion so far this year.
Vanguard's research team noted that by the end of July, Alphabet, Amazon, Meta, Microsoft and Oracle had sold about $132 billion of bonds this year, including a single offering of roughly $53 billion and a bond that does not come due for 100 years. CNBC reported CoreWeave carries about $51 billion of total debt, and Reuters reported on October 22 that a market measure of Meta's credit risk hit a record high.
There is another side: one investment manager told CNBC that worries about Meta's debt are overblown, and cloud customers say they cannot get enough AI chips. Skeptics reply that much of the capacity is sold to AI labs that are losing money. Nobody knows who is right, but an S&P 500 fund owns a large slice of that spending and debt either way.
What SCHD Owns Instead
SCHD follows a rules-based index. A company needs at least ten straight years of dividends, real estate trusts are excluded, and the half of remaining stocks with the lowest yields is cut. The rest are ranked on cash flow compared with debt, return on equity, dividend yield and five-year dividend growth, and the top 100 make it. That second step is why the giants never get in: their dividends are tiny or nonexistent, and Amazon pays none.
According to Schwab's page as of October 12, reported by TheStreet, the largest holdings are Texas Instruments, Procter & Gamble, Qualcomm and Coca-Cola, each around 4.25% to 4.5%. Others near the top include ConocoPhillips, Chevron, UnitedHealth, Amgen, Merck, PepsiCo and Verizon. Technology is about 16% of the fund after this year's rebuild, and none of the nine big names from the S&P 500 list appears among its holdings.
SCHD is concentrated too: its top ten make up about 41% of the fund. But it is a different kind of concentration, with companies selling soap, soda, oil, medicine and phone service rather than one technology wave. The index is rebuilt every March, and a Motley Fool piece noted that former holdings like UPS and Lockheed Martin disappointed while in the fund. The rules pick companies with a record of paying, not winners.
$100,000 in SCHD vs VOO, RSP, VIG and QQQ
With $100,000 invested on October 3, 2016, every dividend reinvested and nothing added or sold, the results today are:
- SCHD: about $352,000
- VOO (S&P 500): about $416,000
- RSP (Invesco equal-weight S&P 500): about $310,000
- VIG (Vanguard Dividend Appreciation): about $353,000
- QQQ (Nasdaq 100): about $636,000
The path matters. At the end of 2017, SCHD was at about $126,000 and VOO about $127,000; 2018, about $119,000 against $121,000; 2019, $151,000 against $159,000; 2020, $174,000 against $188,000; and 2021, $226,000 against $243,000. For five years the dividend fund ran almost even with the index. At the end of 2022 SCHD led, about $219,000 against $199,000. Then the gap opened: 2023, $229,000 against $251,000; 2024, $256,000 against $314,000; 2025, $267,000 against $369,000. Almost all of the index's lead was built in three years, 2023 to 2025, when AI took over the market.
Owning the giants paid: the more of them you owned, the more you made. VIG, which holds Microsoft, Apple and Broadcom, finished at about $353,000, practically tied with SCHD's $352,000, so owning some giants through a dividend fund bought a different ride and about half the paycheck. QQQ's $636,000 came with a 49% gain in 2020, a 33% loss in 2022 that took the account from about $350,000 to about $236,000, and a 55% gain in 2023.
The Paycheck: Dividend Income Over 10 Years
After reinvesting for ten years, the same $100,000 pays about $10,500 a year (about $876 a month) in SCHD, versus about $4,400 (about $368 a month) in VOO, about $4,500 in RSP, about $5,300 in VIG and about $2,800 in QQQ. The fund that grew the most pays the least.
If you spent every dividend instead, $100,000 bought about 7,116 SCHD shares at about $14 each (split-adjusted). They paid about $3,192 in 2017, about $4,811 in 2020 and about $7,454 in 2025, higher every single year, for about $54,000 in total cash. VOO paid about $2,205 in 2017 and about $3,569 in 2025, with a drop in 2020 when many companies cut dividends, for about $29,500 in total. The VOO shares themselves grew more: about $354,000 versus about $251,000 for SCHD. Adding cash received, SCHD comes to about $305,000 and VOO about $383,000.
On yield on cost, SCHD shares cost about $14 and paid about $1.05 last year, about 7.5% on what you paid. VOO shares cost about $198 and paid about $7.07, about 3.5%. SCHD's income came from yearly raises, not a high starting yield. For more on dividend growth, see DGRO vs SCHD: The Dividend Growth Stall Investors Need to See.
When SCHD Hurt, and When It Paid
2022: The Year the Top Ten Fell
In the 2020 pandemic crash the two funds fell almost the same: about 33% for SCHD and about 34% for VOO. 2022 was different. VOO lost about 18% for the year and was down about 24.5% at its October low. SCHD lost about 3% and was down about 17% from its January high at its worst, in late September. Spent dividends rose from about $5,335 to about $6,076, a raise of about 14%. QQQ lost about 33% and VIG about 10%. The more giants a fund held, the more it hurt.
2023 to 2025: The Long Wait
VOO returned about 26% in 2023, 25% in 2024 and 18% in 2025. SCHD returned about 4.5%, 11.5% and 4%. By the end of 2025, $100,000 was worth about $369,000 in VOO and about $267,000 in SCHD, a gap of about $102,000. Still, the spent-dividend paycheck rose from about $6,305 to $7,076 to $7,454, raises of about 4%, 12% and 5%. VOO's payout grew from about $3,210 to $3,569 from a much smaller base.
Giving up would have been costly. Switching from SCHD into VOO on New Year's Eve 2025 would have grown about $267,000 by about 13% to about $301,000, while staying put gives about $352,000. Switching at the worst moment cost about $51,000 in under ten months.
2026: The Flip
SCHD closed 2025 at about $27.43 a share and is about $35.33 now: about 29% on price and about 32% with dividends reinvested. VOO is up about 12% on price and about 13% with dividends. QQQ is up about 14.5% on price, RSP about 13.5% and VIG about 11, so the giants had a decent year; SCHD simply had a much better one. The gap shrank from about $102,000 to about $64,000.
Part of this is the March rebuild adding names like Texas Instruments and Qualcomm; part is money rotating toward cheaper, steadier companies. There is a catch: price ran ahead of payouts, which are roughly flat this year (about 25, 25 and 27 cents in three payments versus 25, 26 and 26 a year earlier), so yield fell from above 3.5% to about 3%. Ten months do not prove a strategy, just as three bad years did not disprove it. The funds took turns, and when two good investments take turns, owning both is usually smarter than guessing whose turn is next. See also SCHD and SCHG: The 70/30 Core Satellite Strategy.
Equal Weight or the Simple 50/50 Split?
Equal weight (RSP) shrinks the top ten to about 2% of your money, but over these ten years it grew $100,000 to only about $310,000 and trailed both funds. One published analysis found equal weight beat the regular index by about 7.5 percentage points a year from March 2000 to March 2010 and had its weakest ten-year run in the decade to May 2026: a tool that works when giants crash and lags when they lead.
A simpler approach is a 50/50 split. $50,000 in each of SCHD and VOO, dividends reinvested, grew to about $384,000 and pays about $7,460 a year, about $620 a month. That is about $32,000 less than owning only the index, but about $3,000 a year more income, and it cuts exposure to the top ten roughly in half, to about 19 cents of every dollar. For a retiree spending dividends, the split paid out about $41,900 in cash over ten years, is worth about $302,000, and pays about $5,600 a year, about $469 a month.
Pick the split once, then check yearly and move money back toward 50/50: trimming the giants when they run and adding to SCHD when it lags. This channel treats SCHD as the foundation and VOO as the growth engine. Related reading: 3-Bucket Dividend Strategy: DIVO, NOBL & SCHD for Retirement.
Watch the Full Video
For a visual walkthrough of every chart and year-by-year number, watch the full video: I Put $100,000 in SCHD for 10 Years and Skipped the AI Stocks. The natural next step is the head-to-head, What If You Invest $100k In VOO vs SCHD? Would you own the top ten, skip them, or split it? Tell me in the comments.
Owning the top ten has been the right call for the last decade. Owning only the biggest names means one story decides everything. A split gives you both stories.
I am not a financial advisor and this is not financial advice. Results are a hypothetical model from one start date; different dates give different results. Dividends can be cut. Past performance does not guarantee future results.
